Chaophraya Dialogue 11

Bangkok, Thailand: Key opinion makers from India and Pakistan, including parliamentarians, former diplomats, military officers, journalists from the print and electronic media, academics and policy experts met in Bangkok for the 11th round of the Chaophraya Dialogue from 18 – 20 December 2012, organized by the Jinnah Institute (JI) and the Australia India Institute (AII).

The Chaophraya Dialogue is an Indo-Pak Track-II initiative jointly undertaken by the Jinnah Institute (JI) and Australia India Institute (AII) to encourage informed discussion of bilateral relations and enhance stakes in peace. The dialogue is primarily meant to give an opportunity to members of the policy and media communities and other groups in India and Pakistan to interact with each other on a sustained basis.

It provided a very useful forum when the official dialogue process between India and Pakistan had ruptured, following the 26/11 attacks in Mumbai. During this period the Chaophraya Dialogue managed to bring together senior interlocutors from India and Pakistan multiple times. The Dialogue encourages participants to share the conclusions of each round with their respective governments.

Chaophraya Dialogue 11
18 – 20 December, 2012

Conference Statement
The participants noted with satisfaction that the resumed Pakistan India Dialogue Process was registering positive movement and expressed the hope that it would continue to make progress towards the solution of all outstanding issues between the two countries. Furthermore, they unanimously agreed to the following:

1. They expressed solidarity and sympathy with the long suffering Afghan people and recommend that any solution should respect the territorial integrity of Afghanistan;

2. They asserted that the conflict in Afghanistan does not have a military solution and has to be resolved politically;

3. They recommended that any resolution of the conflict should satisfy the aspirations of all the segments of the population in the country and that it should be led by Afghans themselves;

4. They reiterated that all countries should commit themselves to non-interference in the internal affairs of Afghanistan and that Afghanistan’s soil should not be used for actions prejudicial to peace and security in any country;

5. They recommended that conditions be created inside Afghanistan that enables all Afghan refugees living outside Afghanistan to return to their home country;

6. They recommended that pledges made by the international community at various fora need to be fulfilled to support Afghanistan’s rehabilitation and economic development;

7. They recommended that India and Pakistan engage in a frank bilateral discussion on their roles in the stability and progress of Afghanistan;

8. They recommended that India and Pakistan should explore the possibility of undertaking joint projects in Afghanistan on Information Technology, training and education, telecommunication, healthcare, agriculture, capacity building, etc.;

9. They emphasized that the vision of Afghanistan being a the gateway for trade and commerce between South and Central Asia and strongly urged India and Pakistan to work towards realizing this vision;

Conflict Prevention 1: Trade
1. They noted the headway India and Pakistan have recently made on bilateral trade and economic relations and recommended that Pakistan should grant and operationalize the MFN status to India;

2. They recommended that a mechanism for resolution of bilateral trade disputes/grievances be created that includes private sector participation from Pakistan and India. Further, both countries should develop the capacity for evidence based dispute resolution;

3. They recommended an improvement in trade related infrastructure through opening up of more trade routes such as Khokrapar-Munnabao, greater facilities at Wagha-Attari Integrated Check Posts with an increased capacity to handle more trucks at Wagha. Moreover, cross-LoC trade should be enhanced;

4. They recommended that bilateral trade should be facilitated by availability of banking services and the existing agreement onk opening bank branches should be expeditiously operationalized;

In the area of services, they recommended the following:
• Group tourism through accredited travel agents should be facilitated immediately;

• Students from India and Pakistan should be encouraged to study in each other’s educational institutions;

• Remaining hurdles for facilitating healthcare visits should be removed;

• Cross border business related services including Information Technology and skilled manpower should be promoted.

5. They recommended that bilateral FDI should be brought on par with the most liberal FDI regime in either India or Pakistan;

6. They recommended that a bilateral committee be set up with representation from the private sector, government and independent experts to monitor progress on the overall bilateral economic relationship and assess implementation of specific measures that facilitate trade in goods, services and investment. It should report annually to parliaments in both countries;

7. They emphasized that the bilateral economic relationship should not be allowed to be disrupted by security issues.

Conflict Prevention 2: Crisis Stability
1. They encouraged transparency in strategic nuclear matters;

2. They urged that India and Pakistan should discuss the structure and growth of their nuclear arsenals;

3. They recommended that nuclear arms control as a means of enhancing understanding, security, stability and the consequent need for verification should be taken up;

4. They felt there was a need to define credible minimum nuclear deterrence;

5. They identified the need to discuss measures that prevent the pre-delegation of nuclear launch authority;

6. They urged that contingencies that potentially lead to nuclear escalation should be addressed;

7. They urged that India and Pakistan should refrain from missile testing during periods of tension;

8. They emphasized that measures be taken that can prevent radioactive material from falling into the wrong hands.

Conflict Prevention 3: People to People Contacts
1. With people to people contact underpinning and paving the way for official dialogues in regions across the world, they recognized that broadened people to people contact is imperative for improving Indo-Pak relations;

2. They felt that the biggest hurdle in people to people contact is the restrictive visa regime. While recognizing security concerns kkkk which have led to this, they welcomed the recent progress on this issue with easier availability of visas for certain categories such as senior citizens, minors and business persons;

3. They strongly recommended that this be taken forward with the addition of further categories for annual/multi-year multiple entry visas for other categories such as journalists, academics, patients, writers, artists, sports persons, group tourists, etc., who are either accredited or recognized by their relevant national bodies;

4. To facilitate easy access of visas for the general population, they suggested the exploration of a trusted visitor program along the lines of that implemented by the United States;

5. To facilitate easier cross border travel, they recommended that steps be taken to increase flight connectivity as well as increasing the number and capacity of land and rail crossing points.


Indian Delegates Pakistan Delegates
Prof. Amitabh Mattoo – Director, Australia India Institute Aziz Ahmad Khan – former Ambassador and Hon. Vice President Jinnah Institute
Raashid Alvi – Member Rajya Sabha Dr. Ijaz Nabi – senior academic and economic expert
Nirupama Subramanian – Associate Editor, The Hindu Hameedullah Jan Afridi – parliamentarian and former Federal Minister for Environment
Gopalaswami Parthasarathy- former Ambassador Marvi Sirmed- human rights activist
Baijayant Jay Panda – Member Lok Sabha Rustam Shah Mohmand – former Ambassador
Vivek Katju – former Ambassador Saleem Safi – Anchor and senior journalist
Ila Patnaik- Professor – National Institute of Public Finance and Policy Dr. Zafar Iqbal Cheema – academic and nuclear expert
Vice Admiral (Retd.) Vijay Shankar- nuclear security expert Ayaz Wazir – former Ambassador
Dr. Happymon Jacob – Assistant Professor, Centre of International Politics, Organisation and Disarmament, JNU Dr. Aisha Ghaus Pasha – Director, Institute of Public Policy, Beaconhouse National University
Dr. Mallika Joseph – Executive Director, Regional Centre for Strategic Studies Salman Zaidi – Deputy Director, Jinnah Institute
Thiranjala Weerasinghe – Program Officer, Regional Centre for Strategic Studies Mehmoona Bashar – Public Affairs Officer, Jinnah Institute


Coverage: Express Tribune